Last updated on May 7, 2026
Magic is going mainstream. But not today…This urban-cozy sequel to Unmagical: a witchy mystery will appeal to fans of The Craft and Freaks and Geeks.
About the book:
When Cate Corey returns to college after spending Spring Break in her enchanted hometown, she’s tasked with tracking down a wayward witch.
Finding the girl is easy.
The real trick will be stopping her from revealing their secrets to the world.
With the safety of everyone at home on the line, and witch hunters on her trail, Cate must choose between endangering her community and betraying a friend.
How do you protect yourself from someone else’s fear?
AI Disclosure: I have not used AI in the creation of this work — there are 10-25 drafts in my Google Drive folder to prove it. You can pry my em dashes from my cold, dead hands.
Purchase Details:
The ebook is available for $1.99 wherever books are sold, but I hope you’ll choose to purchase it from my shop, where I get to keep the majority of the money you spend on my work.
Paperbacks purchased through my shop will come signed with stickers and character art. You can get free shipping during this sale with promo code: COZY. Unsigned paperbacks are available through your favorite retailer, in case I sell out in the shop.
Complete the trilogy:
Reviews:
Unforgivable combines the best elements of a mystery with modern-day magic and a touch of daring heroines. I enjoyed reading this book as much as I did the first. I can relate with Cate feeling the pressure of being almost extraordinary but not quite meeting expectations of family and friends. I encourage anyone reading this book to take a moment of reflection and find what makes them feel ordinary because it might just be what makes you unique. – Cecil, Amazon
The beginning of the second book gave me The Craft vibes and I was loving it. I like how Cate is going back to college to finish this life journey she started. She takes on the challenge of trying to help another witch who could use some guidance. It makes it even harder when that witch does not think she needs any help. There was so much going on and kept me guessing as to what would happen next. I am looking forward to seeing how this trilogy wraps up. – SusanReadsCozies, Goodreads